Current:Home > MyRobert Brown|Second Romanian gymnast continuing to fight for bronze medal in Olympic floor final -FutureFinance
Robert Brown|Second Romanian gymnast continuing to fight for bronze medal in Olympic floor final
Will Sage Astor View
Date:2025-04-10 19:16:36
Jordan Chiles isn't the only gymnast still fighting for a bronze medal from the floor exercise final at the 2024 Paris Olympics.
Sabrina Maneca-Voinea and Robert Brownthe Romanian Gymnastics Federation filed an appeal with the Swiss Federal Tribunal, the federation announced Monday. They are challenging the Court of Arbitration for Sport's rejection earlier this month of Voinea's complaint that she was wrongly docked 0.10 points for going out of bounds during the floor final.
Voinea's appeal is the latest twist in a convoluted case that has caused an international furor given Chiles was stripped of her bronze medal on the final day of the Paris Olympics despite having done nothing wrong. USA Gymnastics and the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee have said they are also planning an appeal to the Swiss Federal Tribunal, citing procedural errors by the CAS and video evidence that refutes the premise for CAS' ruling.
Chiles initially finished fifth in the Aug. 5 floor final, her 13.666 putting her behind Ana Barbosu and Voinea. The Romanians each scored 13.7, but Barbosu placed higher because of a better execution score. Cecile Landi, who is Chiles’ personal coach in addition to being the U.S. coach in Paris, appealed Chiles' difficulty score, arguing she had not been given full credit for a tour jete, a leap.
A review panel agreed, and the additional 0.100 elevated the American ahead of both Romanians into third place. Romania appealed to CAS on Aug. 6, challenging the timing of Chiles’ appeal. CAS ruled Aug. 10 that Chiles' appeal was submitted four seconds too late and told the International Gymnastics Federation to re-order the standings.
2024 Paris Olympics: Follow USA TODAY’s coverage of the biggest names and stories of the Games.
The following day, the IOC ordered Chiles' medal to be reallocated, making Barbosu the bronze medalist. Though USA Gymnastics said it has video showing, conclusively, that Landi submitted the appeal in time, the IOC considered the matter settled and Barbosu received her medal Aug. 9.
But according to Voinea and the Romanians, all of this would have been a moot point had Voinea not received a deduction for going out of bounds, which replays show she did not do. Without the 0.10 out-of-bounds deduction, Voinea's score would have been a 13.8, putting her ahead of Chiles – both her initial score and the one after the appeal – and Barbosu.
Voinea and Romania appealed her score to CAS, but the tribunal rejected it, saying it was a "field-of-play" decision. Though Voinea had filed an inquiry during the competition, it was for her difficulty score, not the out-of-bounds call. Asking CAS to reverse it after the fact would be to second-guess the judges, the tribunal wrote in its reasoned decision, issued Aug. 14.
"The decision as to whether a 0.1 deduction was appropriate is a textbook example of a ‘field of play’ decision, one that does not permit the arbitrators to substitute their views for that of the referee," CAS wrote. "It warrants the non-interference of CAS as it entails the exercise of judgment by the referee, based on expertise in the ‘field of play’.
"Whether the judgment is right or wrong, it cannot be reviewed."
The USA TODAY app gets you to the heart of the news — fast. Download for award-winning coverage, crosswords, audio storytelling, the eNewspaper and more.
veryGood! (25164)
Related
- The Best Stocking Stuffers Under $25
- World Cup schedule for knockout stage: USA gets Sweden first round, Morocco faces France
- ACLU files lawsuit against drag show restrictions in Texas
- Exclusive: Survey says movie and TV fans side with striking actors and writers
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- Investigators say weather worsened quickly before plane crash that killed 6 in Southern California
- Keep quiet, put down the phone: Bad behavior in blockbusters sparks theater-etiquette discussion
- Ginger has been used for thousands of years. What are its health benefits?
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- Grand Canyon West in northern Arizona reopens attractions a day after fatal tour bus rollover
Ranking
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- Isla Fisher and Sacha Baron Cohen Pack on the PDA During Greece Vacation
- US military may put armed troops on commercial ships in Strait of Hormuz to stop Iran seizures
- Kim Cattrall Makes Surprise And Just Like That Appearance Ahead of Season Finale Cameo
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- This beer is made from recycled wastewater and is completely safe to consume
- Watch live outside US Senate buildings after potential active shooter call causes evacuations
- Pregnant Kourtney Kardashian Shares Glimpse Into Beachside Getaway With Travis Barker
Recommendation
Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
Miko Air Purifiers: Why People Everywhere Are Shopping For This Home Essential
Consultant recommends $44.4M plan to raze, rehabilitate former state prison site in Pittsburgh
$4M settlement reached with family of man who died in bed bug-infested jail cell
Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
U.S. Women’s World Cup tie with Portugal draws overnight audience of 1.35 million on Fox
Swaths of the US are living through a brutal summer. It’s a climate wake-up call for many
Family pleads for help in search for missing Georgia mother of 4