Current:Home > reviewsNCAA, Pac-12, USC set to begin trial today with NLRB over athletes' employment status -FutureFinance
NCAA, Pac-12, USC set to begin trial today with NLRB over athletes' employment status
View
Date:2025-04-15 06:50:17
An administrative law judge will begin proceedings Tuesday in a National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) complaint against the NCAA, the Pac-12 Conference and the University of Southern California that alleges they have unlawfully misclassified college athletes as "student-athletes" rather than employees.
The case specifically revolves around athletes in football, men’s basketball and women’s basketball at USC. However, it carries the potential for much broader implications across college sports. And it is among the reasons that the NCAA and its member schools and conferences have been vigorously lobbying Congress for legislation that would include a provision preventing athletes from becoming school employees.
Here’s a look at where this came from and where it may go.
What are the origins of the case?
In September 2021, the Biden Administration’s appointee as NLRB general counsel, Jennifer Abruzzo, issued a memorandum saying that she views college athletes as employees of their schools under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).
At the time, University of Illinois labor law professor Michael LeRoy told USA TODAY Sports that Abruzzo’s memo amounted to her "inviting a petition from players to form a union at a private institution. She's put it out there. She's saying, 'Bring it.'"
In February 2022, the National College Players Association, a group that advocates on behalf of college athletes, did just that. But there ended up being more.
The joint-employer theory and why it matters
When the NLRB’s Los Angeles office issued its complaint in May 2023, as well as when it amended that complaint in September, it alleged that the NCAA, Pac-12 and USC have been joint employers of the athletes because the NCAA and Pac-12 had control over the athletes' working conditions and "administered a common labor policy" with USC regarding those conditions.
If this theory of the case prevails, it could have implications for all of college athletics. The NLRA applies to private employers. State laws govern public employees, and many states have laws that do not allow public employees to unionize.
USC is a private school. The NCAA and the Pac-12 are private, non-profit organizations. If the NCAA and a major college-sports conference are found to be employers of athletes, then "every college athlete has a private employer," Gabe Feldman, director of the Tulane Sports Law Program and Tulane University's associate provost for NCAA compliance, said Monday.
As such, it would open the door to the possibility of unionization and collective bargaining for athletes at public schools, Feldman said.
An effort to unionize football players at Northwestern University ended in August 2015, when the full NLRB said that because the board has no jurisdiction over public schools, addressing the Northwestern effort would run counter to the NLRA’s charge that the board create stable and predictable labor environments in various industries. Under a joint-employer theory, that issue could go away.
The NLRB L.A. office’s side
The complaint cited excerpts from the USC athletics department's Student-Athlete Handbook and its Social Media Policy & Guidelines for Student Athletes, which set a variety of regulations that athletes must follow.
It also alleged that USC, the Pac-12 and the NCAA "have intentionally misclassified the [p]layers as non-employee student athletes in order to deprive" them of their right under the NLRA to organize or bargain collectively and to "discourage (them) from engaging in protected concerted activities".
The USC, Pac-12 and NCAA’s side
Each of the three entities has filed a argument for dismissal, offering separately or collectively a set of arguments including:
▶ The contents of USC’s handbook do not constitute a set of "rules" that violate the NLRA. They are "merely recommendations, or general admonitions" and "do not rise to the level of work rules and their maintenance does not constitute an unfair labor practice."
▶ Under the First Amendment, they cannot be compelled to use a phrase other than "student-athletes" to describe students who play for the teams in question.
▶ The Pac-12 is not subject to the NLRA because 10 of its 12 members are public schools. That makes the conference a "political subdivision," in the context of the NLRA, because the conference's governing board comprises school presidents and chancellors who answer to public officials in their states.
What happens now
What originally had been set to be one several-week trial had to be re-arranged because of a conflict in the judge’s schedule. Instead, there will up to three days of pre-trial matters this week, then testimony Dec. 18-20, Jan. 22-Feb 2, and, if needed, Feb. 26-29.
The ruling of an administrative law judge can be appealed to the full National Labor Relations Board, and a board decision can be appealed in federal court.
veryGood! (992)
Related
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- Why everyone in the labor market is being picky
- 'Billionaire Bunker' Florida home listed at $85 million. Jeff Bezos got it for $79 million
- Minneapolis City Council approves site for new police station; old one burned during 2020 protest
- Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
- Israeli airstrikes target Hamas in Jabaliya refugee camp; Gaza officials say civilians killed
- In Elijah McClain trial, closing arguments begin for Colorado officer charged in death
- Australian premier to protest blogger’s vague detention conditions while meeting Chinese president
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- An Indianapolis student is fatally shot outside a high school
Ranking
- Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
- Judge gives life in prison for look-out in Florida gang shooting that killed 3 and injured 20
- Jung Kook's 'Golden' is 24-karat pop: Best songs on the BTS star's solo album
- Jennifer Lopez says Ben Affleck makes her feels 'more beautiful' than her past relationships
- Romantasy reigns on spicy BookTok: Recommendations from the internet’s favorite genre
- AP PHOTOS: Scenes of pain and destruction endure in week 4 of the latest Israel-Gaza conflict
- Taliban appeal to Afghan private sector to help those fleeing Pakistan’s mass deportation drive
- Federal appeals court upholds Illinois semiautomatic weapons ban
Recommendation
Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
Michigan fires Stalions, football staffer at center of sign-stealing investigation, AP source says
These Are the Early Black Friday 2023 Sales Worth Shopping Right Now
NASA spacecraft discovers tiny moon around asteroid during close flyby
Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
What's Making Us Happy: A guide to your weekend viewing and listening
Malcolm X arrives — finally — at New York's Metropolitan Opera
2 killed in shooting at graveyard during Mexico’s Day of the Dead holiday